Sold Sep 14, 2026$570,000
Asking $594,900 · 96% of asking · 38 days on market
4 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,728 sqft · House
501 Manning Way, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Listing courtesy of Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva · MLS# 1969478
The Highlands of Lake Geneva
Subdivision, no association found on Geneva Lake, in the City of Lake Geneva. Off-lake.
Subdivision, no association foundOff-lake
Researched by ELITE Lake Real Estate · Last checked November 2026 · Sources
Homes for sale in The Highlands of Lake Geneva
No homes in The Highlands of Lake Geneva are listed for sale right now. See every home for sale in City of Lake Geneva or get listing alerts for The Highlands of Lake Geneva.
The shaded area is The Highlands of Lake Geneva as recorded in county plat maps. Boundaries are approximate; confirm lot lines with a survey.
Sold in The Highlands of Lake Geneva in the last 12 months
1 home sold, at a median of $570,000 after a median 38 days on market, for 96% of the asking price.
Sold Sep 14, 2026About The Highlands of Lake Geneva
The Highlands of Lake Geneva is a platted subdivision. It is not known whether a homeowners association applies.
Where it is: Manning Way, Highland Way and Skyline Dr
Lake access
The subdivision is off-lake, within walking distance of downtown, the lake and the beach.
Amenities
A paved walking and biking trail to downtown may run along some lots. Confirm for each home.
Rental rules
Can you rent out a home in The Highlands of Lake Geneva?
The City of Lake Geneva allows them with a license. The Highlands of Lake Geneva's own rules aren't published, so we check them before you buy.
City of Lake Geneva
Allowed with a City license- Guests stay at least 2 nights, and the next guest can't arrive until 7 days after the last one arrived (Ordinance 24-13, adopted November 25, 2024).
- Rentals run in one season of up to 180 consecutive days a year that the owner picks. Outside it, the next guest can't arrive for 29 days.
- An annual City license ($1,300 a year), renewed by January 31, plus a state license, room tax permit, business license, building inspection and insurance.
- Licenses don't transfer. A buyer needs a new license before renting.
- A designated operator within 25 miles, reachable 24/7, and at least 2 off-street parking spaces plus 1 for each bedroom over two.
- Every listing must show the City license number and the parking. Renting without a license is $1,000 a day.
Confirm with: City of Lake Geneva
The Highlands of Lake Geneva rules
Not publishedNo community rental rules were found. As of October 19, 2026, the city short-term rental registry showed two licensed short-term rentals in this subdivision.
Rules checked November 2026. Next review February 2027. General information, not legal advice. Check another address
Thinking about The Highlands of Lake Geneva?
Get new listing alerts for this community, or ask me anything about it: lake rights, dues, rental rules, what homes sell for. Buying from Chicago? I'll tour any home for you and send a video the same day.
Sources
Researched by ELITE Lake Real Estate from county land records, town and village rules, and association and club information. Dues, amenities and rules change over time, so confirm everything for a specific home before you buy.