Sold Jul 21, 2026$1,800,000
Asking $1,895,000 · 95% of asking · 91 days on market
5 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,636 sqft · House
603 Agaming Rd, Fontana, WI 53125
Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Starck Real Estate · MLS# 1951205
Indian Hills
Lake access association on Geneva Lake, in the Village of Fontana. Lakefront and lake access.
Also known as: Indian Hills 1st Addition, Indian Hills Subdivision of Block 6
Lake access associationLakefront and lake access
Researched by ELITE Lake Real Estate · Last checked November 2026 · Sources
Homes for sale in Indian Hills
No homes in Indian Hills are listed for sale right now. See every home for sale in Village of Fontana or get listing alerts for Indian Hills.
The shaded area is Indian Hills as recorded in county plat maps. Boundaries are approximate; confirm lot lines with a survey.
Sold in Indian Hills in the last 12 months
3 homes sold, at a median of $599,000 after a median 26 days on market, for 97% of the asking price.
Sold Jul 21, 2026
Sold Apr 24, 2026$599,000
Asking $619,900 · 97% of asking · 26 days on market
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,403 sqft · House
787 Odsila Way, Fontana, WI 53125
Listing courtesy of Mahler Sotheby's International Realty-Lake Country · MLS# 1951791
Sold Mar 20, 2026$505,000
Asking $519,900 · 97% of asking · 6 days on market
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,820 sqft · House
770 Odsila Way, Fontana, WI 53125
Listing courtesy of Shorewest Realtors, Inc. · MLS# 1949239
About Indian Hills
Indian Hills has a lake access association, the Indian Hills Association. A separate nonprofit, Indian Hills First Addition Association Inc., also exists. How lake rights are divided between the two is not documented, so confirm the rights for each home.
Where it is: South shore, west of the Abbey area. S Lakeshore Dr, Sioux Dr, Aweogon Rd, Sauk Trail, Agaming Rd, Ayataia, Adahi, Akwenasa, Nohegon and Odsila Ways, Shoshone Rd, Mesita/Meista Rd, Geneva Ln and Indian Hills Rd.
Lake access
A few lots are lakefront on S Lakeshore Dr, and most are off the lake. Not every home in the Indian Hills area may have access to the association lakefront. Verify lake rights for each parcel.
Amenities
The association lakefront park has a swimming pier, a fishing pier, a picnic area, a playground and a beach. Buoys may be available. The association also has a kayak rack; in 2024 the Village amended its ordinance at the association's request to allow 20 spaces. Confirm current amenities with the association.
Membership and dues
Dues vary and change over time. Ask for the current amount before you make an offer.
Rental rules
Can you rent out a home in Indian Hills?
It depends on where the home sits in the Village of Fontana. Indian Hills's details are below.
Village of Fontana
Depends on location- Vacation rental homes are allowed by right only in the Village Center, Abbey Springs, and the Abbey Resort, Abbey Ridge and Abbey Villas areas.
- Everywhere else: single-family homes only, one rental per 7-day period, inside one 180-day window a year.
- Village license, state license, room tax permit, inspections and insurance.
- Some associations ban short-term rentals, such as Buena Vista Club.
Confirm with: Village of Fontana Zoning Administrator
Indian Hills rules
Not publishedIndian Hills is not on the Village list of areas where vacation rental homes (VRH) are allowed by right. Only tourist rooming house (TRH) licensing applies, and the Village rental license list shows one TRH license, in Indian Hills 1st Addition. No community rental rules were found.
Rules checked November 2026. Next review February 2027. General information, not legal advice. Check another address
Thinking about Indian Hills?
Get new listing alerts for this community, or ask me anything about it: lake rights, dues, rental rules, what homes sell for. Buying from Chicago? I'll tour any home for you and send a video the same day.
Sources
Researched by ELITE Lake Real Estate from county land records, town and village rules, and association and club information. Dues, amenities and rules change over time, so confirm everything for a specific home before you buy.